Plainview, NY

About Lehmann Insurance

Serving Plainview and the Nassau County and Western Suffolk County community since

Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Plainview

At Lehmann Insurance, we have deep roots right here in Plainview. For , our team has helped families and businesses across Plainview navigate the world of insurance with confidence. Our presence in Nassau County and Western Suffolk County means we understand the unique needs and concerns of our neighbors.

What truly sets us apart is our longstanding commitment to personal service. We believe insurance should be about protecting what you value most, not just policies and paperwork. When you choose us, you get a local team dedicated to building real relationships—whether you’re from Plainview, Syosset, or Bethpage, you’ll always be treated like part of our agency family.

A Legacy of Trust in Plainview

Lehmann Insurance was founded in with the mission to provide honest and reliable insurance guidance to the Plainview community. The earliest days were spent earning the trust of families and local businesses as we helped secure their futures.

Over the years, our agency has grown alongside Plainview and the neighboring towns like Woodbury and Hicksville, always maintaining our tradition of attentive service. Our focus has never changed: building lasting relationships and supporting our clients through every stage of life.

Comprehensive Insurance Solutions

We offer a wide range of insurance options designed to fit the needs of individuals, families, and businesses throughout Plainview and the greater Nassau and Western Suffolk area.

Our coverage options include:

We take the time to help you find the policies that suit your unique goals, providing straightforward answers every step of the way.

Committed to Our Plainview Community

Our agency is more than just a business in Plainview—we’re proud to be active members of the community. Whether it’s participating in local events or supporting neighborhood initiatives in towns like Farmingdale and Old Bethpage, we value every connection we build with our neighbors.

Giving back is an essential part of who we are. We strive to be a positive force, supporting causes that matter and always being available when our community needs guidance or a helping hand.

Local Knowledge, Personalized Service

With years of experience serving Plainview and surrounding areas—including Melville, Jericho, and Westbury—we know the unique risks and opportunities our region faces. Our understanding of Nassau County and Western Suffolk County’s neighborhoods, from bustling centers to quiet suburbs, helps us offer insurance solutions that truly fit our clients’ lives.

Our local expertise means we can tailor your policies to the realities of living and working here—whether it’s coastal storms, local regulations, or community dynamics. Every policy we recommend is a reflection of our firsthand knowledge of this area and its people.

Deep Local Expertise
Decades of experience with the needs and concerns of Plainview and the Nassau County and Western Suffolk County region.
Personalized, Face-to-Face Service
We get to know you personally—no call centers, just genuine relationships built right here in the community.
Community Trust
Neighbors in areas like Levittown, Massapequa, and Oyster Bay rely on us because we value honesty, reliability, and long-term support.

What our clients say

“I had been in the market for new home and auto insurance for quite awhile. Everyone on the internet is happy to provide a quote if you fill out information repetitively. I had the good fortune to get connected with Chris Graham in the Edward Lehmann Allstate Office. What a Godsend. Not only is Chris a solid Christian man which is important to me, but also he is a business man I can relate to. He took the time to get to know me and my needs, guided me through the confusing process, and ultimately save me almost $200.00 a month. Comes in handy when you are retired and on a fixed budget. All in all, I recommend Chris to all without hesitation. He is my agent!”
— Steven Gawler

“Worked with Dan Georgia, who was really helpful and simplified the process as much as possible. He also saved me quite a bit of money! Thanks, Dan! Highly recommend!”
— Andrew Blancato

“Very fast, helpful and followed up to make sure I was all set.”
— Christopher Wilson

Our Personal Approach to Insurance

At Lehmann Insurance, personal service means always putting your needs first. We take the time to listen, learn your story, and recommend coverage that makes sense for your life—not just today, but for the years ahead. Building relationships is what we do best, whether you walk into our Plainview office or call us from Mineola or Seaford.

When you work with us, you can expect:

Face-to-face consultations at our Plainview office
Prompt, knowledgeable responses every time you reach out
Honest, clear advice without jargon
Thoughtful policy recommendations based on your needs
A long-term partner you can rely on, year after year

Experience what it’s like to have a local insurance partner who truly cares about protecting your peace of mind.

Thank You for Choosing Lehmann Insurance

We’re grateful for every client who places their trust in the Lehmann Insurance. It means everything to us to be your choice for insurance in Plainview and neighboring communities.

We look forward to serving you for many more years and invite you to stop by, call, or connect online if you have any questions or need advice. Your peace of mind is always our highest priority.